[Assam] Fw: More on UP Elections

Chan Mahanta cmahanta at charter.net
Mon Apr 2 12:28:28 PDT 2007


>Let us also not think that such indicators will make any difference 
>to the average Hobo Diok Litikai Assamese who will go on >electing 
>the Congress again and again.

*** Unfortunately, as things are, it really does NOT matter WHO is 
elected to rule in a given year. The problem is more fundamental, 
more deep rooted. It is systemic.

Look at this:


Finally, I am sure you will agree that it is quite immaterial WHO 
goes past India. That competition is only for that tiny segment of 
the population that has arrived and are now seeking parity with the 
rest of the world's significant powers. It is a trophy issue. For 
those millions ( see 
) that are left out of that 'growing service sector' and struggling 
merely to stay alive.


At 3:00 PM -0400 4/2/07, Barua, Rajen wrote:
>>Summary of the report:
>>  >Now the real kicker is that all this is happening when China is 
>>institutionalizing a system of succession and inner party democracy 
>>to enable it to continue on its current growth trajectory of around 
>>10%. Thus a totalitarian system better suited for thugs is getting 
>>gentrified, while a system of democratic governance is being taken 
>>over by thugs. It is said that Rugby is a game for hooligans played 
>>by gentlemen, while soccer is a game for gentlemen played by 
>>hooligans. The same thing can be said for the systems in China and 
>>(Very intelligent assessment of things)
>>Chandan says:
>>  >Question however is, NOW what?
>>The answer is NOW NOTHING!
>>I think it simply means that the above is another big indicator 
>>that China will get ahead and India will fall behind in a very 
>>short time in a big way which may (or may not) eventually break up 
>>India politically.
>>The other similar indicator was in the report which I recently 
>>posted on India's progress and lack of infrastructure vis-a-vis 
>>Another indicator may be the recently posted article on India's 
>>water resources.
>>These indicators predict dooms for India no doubt. 
>>However, let us not think that Indians will be smart united enough 
>>to think and react and take actions based on these indicators 
>>Indian middle class is now too busy enjoying the material benefits 
>>of Capitalism to worry about such long term indicators. Probably we 
>>need such critical analysis for many many moons to come so that 
>>people will see the light, absorb the reality  and act.
>>Let us also not think that such indicators will make any difference 
>>to the average Hobo Diok Litikai Assamese who will go on electing 
>>the Congress again and again.
>>Hobo Diok
>From: assam-bounces at assamnet.org [mailto:assam-bounces at assamnet.org] 
>On Behalf Of Chan Mahanta
>Sent: Monday, April 02, 2007 9:02 AM
>To: barua25; assam at assamnet.org
>Subject: Re: [Assam] Fw: More on UP Elections
>Insightful article. Thanks for sharing, Rajen. Not that we did not 
>know of it all along, but good to see there are others who see it 
>Question however is, NOW what?
>At 6:30 AM -0500 4/2/07, barua25 wrote:
>>----- Original Message -----
>>From: <mailto:cpasind at yahoo.co.in>Centre for Policy Alternatives
>>Sent: Monday, April 02, 2007 2:29 AM
>>Subject: More on UP Elections
>>Difficult Days Ahead.
>>Predicting the defeat of the Congress Party in the recent Punjab 
>>and Uttaranchal elections was easy enough if one analyzed the 
>>performance of these governments during their term in office. (See 
>>Hardnews of September 2006 to read about the dismal performance of 
>>the Amarinder Singh government) It is only the so-called 
>>professional psephologists and glib television pundits who 
>>invariably get these wrong. Let us also not forget that the India 
>>Today, which has now become India's most popular reading in barber 
>>saloons and dentist waiting rooms, had only last year deemed the 
>>Amarinder Singh government as India's best performing one and had 
>>got the President of India to award him a prize. At that time this 
>>columnist had decried the practice of the President and high 
>>constitutional authorities being the chief guests at such 
>>superficial beauty parades. Ordinary people are better judges of 
>>performance and have always exhibited a great ability to discern 
>>good government from hyped up governance, as they did in the case 
>>of Chandrababu Naidu and SM Krishna in the recent past.
>>But the Prime Minister seems to be busy being a chief guest at 
>>political beauty parades and like functions organized by the 
>>faithful, not realizing that the faithful are faithful to the 
>>office and not to the person. One should take the adulation of the 
>>CII and FICCI with more than a pinch of salt, for the adulation 
>>comes with a price tag. Witness how the State is acquiring land 
>>from the peasants using the most unrealistic valuations to give 
>>them away to so-called developers of SEZ's, but actually in most 
>>instances these are just gigantic real estate plays. Many decades 
>>ago a leading industrialist, Lala Charatram, candidly confessed: 
>>"We support the Prime Minister. We support whoever is the Prime 
>>Minister." But Dr. Manmohan Singh would have got a truer measure of 
>>his popularity with India's multitudes by the attendances to his 
>>meetings in his home state of Punjab. At more than one meeting 
>>policemen vastly outnumbered the public. I have enough Congressmen 
>>testifying to this.
>>Then consider this, if he accepted the offer of Amarinder Singh to 
>>contest the Lok Sabha elections from Amritsar, we would have had a 
>>true world record of his being the first Prime Minister to be 
>>defeated by a professional humorist. But then he was defeated in 
>>South Delhi by one just a little better than that. Right now Dr. 
>>Manmohan Singh is better off being the paying guest of the late 
>>Hiteshwar Saikia's widow in Gauhati and returned to the Rajya Sabha 
>>by the long suffering people of Assam. The point here is that we 
>>have a Prime Minister without a political constituency and hence 
>>out of touch with the reality of India. Unfortunately for him and 
>>for us, ours is a system of government by elected politicians, and 
>>India is paying the price of having a non-political person as its 
>>leader. More on this later.
>>Now the challenge of Uttar Pradesh is on hand. The only question 
>>for the Congress Party is whether it will get more than two dozen 
>>seats or less. We seem to be getting some early indications of how 
>>the cookie is going to crumble with the SPG advising that Rahul 
>>Gandhi curtail his public meetings and the MoS in the Home 
>>Ministry, Sriprakash Jaiswal, advising Rahul Gandhi to follow the 
>>advice of the SPG. I suspect that it is not security but attendance 
>>that is the problem. It's not always true that people in UP vote 
>>entirely according to their caste. Caste is important, but promise 
>>and hope are just as important. In the recent past when political 
>>parties held out the promise of a major change in terms of 
>>performance to meet the aspirations of people for better 
>>government, the people of UP have responded overwhelmingly in 
>>support. Rajiv Gandhi, VP Singh and the BJP held out credible 
>>promise of change and the people rewarded them. It is another 
>>matter that they failed to meet the aspirations of the people even 
>>partially. The result is that people are being left with no option 
>>but to turn to the parties of thugs led by Mulayam Singh and 
>>Mayawati. The Congress is yet to realize that Rahul Gandhi and 
>>retinue of his page three princelings do not still hold out any 
>>hope of rescuing India's biggest state from prolonged 
>>mal-governance. For that you need to have a program based upon a 
>>true appreciation of the problems besetting India and a promise of 
>>solutions. Wearing a prayer cap in Deoband is not a program. It is 
>>a stunt.
>>The problems that beset UP are well known. Not the least among 
>>these is that with Rs.10, 817 (per capita GDP in 2003-4), it has 
>>the second lowest per capita income in India. This is about a third 
>>of the national average. If one were to separate the incomes of 
>>western UP from this, you would be left with a vast hinterland that 
>>is no better off than Bihar (Rs. 5780). If this huge region were a 
>>separate country it would rank right at the bottom between Burundi 
>>($90) and Malawi ($160) in the worlds poverty rankings. One quarter 
>>of UP lives below the official poverty line. This official poverty 
>>line is actually a starvation line, as it is based on an income to 
>>provide a daily food intake norm of 2400 calories. The methodology 
>>used to arrive at a conclusion as to whether people are starving 
>>are not is utterly dubious and self serving and is mostly meant to 
>>show the system in better light. Even so the suggestion that almost 
>>one quarter of the socio-political heartland of India starves 
>>everyday is a horrendous thought and the fact this is now proving 
>>to be a stubborn challenge is a matter of great concern. The 
>>Planning Commission just a few days ago put out a positive picture 
>>about the reduction of the incidence of poverty (starvation) in 
>>India, but if one just got off the tarmac roads for a kilometer or 
>>two the reality will be apparent. The people who live here know 
>>better and all the paid advertisements that UP is now Uttam Pradesh 
>>do not cut much slack here.
>>This is not just the situation in UP. It is the reality in most 
>>rural areas of India. The State in India is in full retreat. It has 
>>largely failed in meeting even the minimum aspirations of the 
>>people. Most rural clusters do not have the minimum health 
>>facilities, just as they do not have schools. Consequently the 
>>infant mortality rate is among the highest in the world and even 
>>today almost 27% of the 15-24 age cohort is illiterate. The State 
>>has withdrawn from establishing new irrigation works to take water 
>>to the parched lands and has largely left it to the peasants to dig 
>>deeper into the earth by digging deeper into their meager resources 
>>for water for the fields. In the last twenty years the State has 
>>not created any worthwhile irrigation and all the additional 
>>millions of irrigated acreage have been by private tubewells. We 
>>all know that this is ruinous to the economy and ecology, but the 
>>Government of India still watches idly. Even the new plan being 
>>contemplated by Montek Singh Ahluwalia shows no inclination to 
>>tackle this situation in any realistic manner. He of course thinks 
>>it is more important to get Wal-Mart into India as it will take 
>>care of the agriculture supply chain? That's what you get when you 
>>have bureaucrats drawing up the national vision.
>>When he first took over office, Dr.Manmohan Singh said that 
>>bureaucratic and administrative reform will be his government's 
>>number one priority. At that time we lauded him for his vision and 
>>commitment to reform. But his government has done little beyond 
>>giving extensions and sinecures to favored babus. Despite Rajiv 
>>Gandhi's known commitment to decentralization, the party headed by 
>>his widow has apparently abandoned the commitment to take 
>>government to the people and give them a say in managing their 
>>daily lives. This power is not with the politician either. It has 
>>passed into the hands of the vast bureaucracy that has taken charge 
>>of India. It is small wonder then the biggest single item in public 
>>spending is the burden of salaries and pensions paid to government 
>>employees as the Central, State and Local levels. At last count 
>>this figure stood close to Rs.195, 000 crores and is still 
>>climbing. This should enable the reader to understand as to why the 
>>Services sector is the fastest growing of India's three economic 
>>sectors. For some perverse reason Public Administration expenditure 
>>is considered a service and this sub sector is the fastest growing 
>>one recording an 11.73% growth rate. So my friends don't think it 
>>is IT that is propelling the growth of the Services sector.
>>In Dr. Manmohan Singh we thought we had a reformer. But what we got 
>>instead was a man with a resume, he has had the best appointments 
>>anyone can aspire to and a Cambridge degree to boot. Our mistake 
>>was that we confused resume with record. He has now clearly lost 
>>his chance to set things right. His term as Prime Minister is 
>>drawing to a close. He is 75 years now and we can well consider him 
>>a lame duck. He has no political constituency and not only has 
>>shown a singular disinclination to take the bull by the horns, but 
>>has also shown that he has no understanding about India's problems. 
>>Nor is he performing the role of Bairam Khan and tutoring the 
>>fledgling prince on the art of administration and the problems of 
>>nation building. But to be fair to him the princeling has not shown 
>>any of Akbar's enthusiasm and curiosity either. So he will wear the 
>>prayer cap at Deoband and do other symbolic things which his 
>>handlers will plan for him. Which means we will have to leave Uttam 
>>Pradesh to Mulayam Singh or Mayawati? India seems heading for even 
>>more difficult days ahead.
>>Now the real kicker is that all this is happening when China is 
>>institutionalizing a system of succession and inner party democracy 
>>to enable it to continue on its current growth trajectory of around 
>>10%. Thus a totalitarian system better suited for thugs is getting 
>>gentrified, while a system of democratic governance is being taken 
>>over by thugs. It is said that Rugby is a game for hooligans played 
>>by gentlemen, while soccer is a game for gentlemen played by 
>>hooligans. The same thing can be said for the systems in China and 
>>Mohan Guruswamy
>>Email: <mailto:mguru at sify.com>mguru at sify.com
>>March 26, 2007
>>Centre for Policy Alternatives
>>94, Uday Park, New Delhi - 49
>>Ph: 91-11-41650997, Fax: 91-11-41650996
>><mailto:cpasind at yahoo.co.in>cpasind at yahoo.co.in
>>Here's a new way to find what you're looking for - 
>>assam mailing list
>>assam at assamnet.org
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.assamnet.org/pipermail/assam-assamnet.org/attachments/20070402/2831cdad/attachment.htm>

More information about the Assam mailing list