[Assam] End the Quota System? in US also?
jaipurschool at yahoo.com
Wed May 23 10:20:56 PDT 2007
Jiski Lathi Uski bhais (whose stick his/her buffalo). or might is right.
In India majority of people are Dalits so quotas will be implemented (but perhaps shoudl not exceed their percentage in Indian population also they should perhaps then be barred for general seats -if they are eligible for quota seats).
In US affirmative action is not implemented the way it is in India. Even in US school textbooks they discuss court cases - for and against quota system. Sometimes it is for (Blacks) sometimes it is against -- since African Americans (called Blacks here) are only 10% of population.
Dilip/Dil Deka <dilipdeka at yahoo.com> wrote:
Is this an attempt to end the (reservation) quota system that was based on caste? If the quota system is struck down, will it cause havoc among the beneficiaries of the reservation policies?
Did the quota system really help in empowering the BC and the OBC, or in due course of time under democracy it was going to happen anyway? Has it helped the masses or just a few of those who were socially handicapped before?
Having been away from India for a long time, I do not have a good perception of the situation in today's India. My request is for someone in India to comment on the news item below so that we can all relate to the issue.
From the Sentinel
EDITORIAL » »
Last updated : MONDAY 21 MAY 2007 The Courts Wisdom
We have said here times without number that it is the Judiciary that has rescued the people of this country from the whims and fancies of politicians. Had it not been for the Judiciary, our lawmakers, most of whom are also excellent lawbreakers, would have perhaps hijacked the nation and its people far beyond recoverable abyss. Whether the repeal of the notorious and discriminatory IM(DT) Act or the verdict that stayed the implementation of 27 per cent OBC quota in higher educational institutions to name only a few in recent times it is the courts wisdom that has saved this nation of ours from being plundered for petty electoral gains. So now as the Supreme Court Bench of Justice Arijit Pasayat and Justice PK Jain has referred the 27 per cent OBC quota case to a larger Bench on the grounds that the issue involved considerable importance of constitutional law having an impact on the entire nation and a larger Bench would have to examine whether the government had
unbridled powers to perpetuate the reservation policies, the nation ought to pause for a while and ponder whether the political class has not already played havoc with the nations just course towards progress in the true sense of the term. The apex courts message of Thursday is clear: that the lawmakers in the country just cannot make laws that address their narrow constituencies and aim to expand them, such as the casteist vote banks.
Not only this. The court also said that the government could not adopt any bullying attitude that could impinge on the fundamental rights of citizens. It pointed out that the governments caste-based reservation policy seemed to be violative of various provisions like Articles 14, 15, 21 and 21 that guarantee fundamental rights. More important and here is the real rebuke the Bench of Justice Pasayat and Justice Jain felt that if the government really wanted to adopt a policy as such for all-inclusive growth and development it should have rather focused on ensuring compulsory education for illiterates, regardless of the caste barrier. The Bench also wanted to know as to why minority educational institutions should be exempted from the purview of the 27 per cent OBC quota policy. These are questions which the government of the day must answer in candid terms and then apologize for having taken the people of the country for a ride so shamelessly. Where is
compulsory education irrespective of the caste barrier? What stops the government from evolving a policy to that end? Just because such a policy will not fetch votes or consolidate vote banks or create new ones? Or is it that the leaders wielding power do not know what it means to drive the nation along the path of progress? As for freeing the minority institutions from the burden of 27 per cent quota, the equation is clear. After all, how can the government dilute an existing and infallible vote bank of the so-called minorities to accommodate other vote-bank interests when these interests can so easily be thrust into other non-minority domains? The court knows how to read the politicians line. One hopes a larger Supreme Court Bench hearing the reservation issue would confirm more of this.
assam mailing list
assam at assamnet.org
Ed.M. - International Education Policy
Harvard Graduate School of Education,
Class of 2005
Copy addresses and emails from any email account to Yahoo! Mail - quick, easy and free. Do it now...
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Assam